AreaStays
Lower Manhattan skyline seen across the Hudson River at dusk, with One World Trade Center rising above the surrounding towers

Gabriel Perez Salazar / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

United States

Where to Stay in New York City

New York City is huge, but you don't need to see all five boroughs to have a great trip — most first-time visitors spend nearly all their time in Manhattan, and a handful of walkable neighborhoods there cover almost everything on a typical bucket list. This guide focuses on those. See a Broadway show in the Theater District, walk the tree-lined blocks of Greenwich Village, browse the boutiques of SoHo's cast-iron streets, or stroll into Central Park from the Upper West Side. The subway connects all of it, so you're never more than a short ride from wherever you're staying.

Quick facts

Best time to visit
Visit in April–June or September–early November. Spring and fall bring mild weather without the summer humidity or the long lines and biting cold of the December holiday season.
Renting a car
Don't rent a car for a Manhattan-based trip. Traffic is slow, parking garages are expensive, and the subway or a short taxi/rideshare gets you everywhere in this guide faster and cheaper.

Where to stay

Times Square lit up at night with giant billboards and Broadway show marquees above the storefronts

Giorgio Galeotti / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

Times Square & Theater District

Best for: First-time visitors, Nightlife

The Washington Square Arch on a sunny day, with trees and pedestrians in Washington Square Park around it

Jean-Christophe BENOIST / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

Greenwich Village

Best for: Couples, Architecture lovers

Greene Street in SoHo at dusk, lined with 19th-century cast-iron building facades, fire escapes, and lit storefronts

CucombreLibre / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

SoHo

Best for: Architecture lovers, Luxury travelers

The Central Park West entrance of the American Museum of Natural History, with its stone columns and carved 'Knowledge' inscription

Alberto-g-rovi / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 3.0

Upper West Side

Best for: Families, Architecture lovers

Compare neighborhoods

AreaBest forAdvantageTrade-off
Times Square & Theater DistrictFirst-time visitorsThe most central, walkable base for Broadway shows and the subway system.Constant crowds and noise, with some of the city's highest hotel rates.
Greenwich VillageCouplesGenuine historic character and a quieter, more residential pace than most of Manhattan.Farther from Times Square and the big Midtown museums than a more central base.
SoHoArchitecture loversSome of the city's best-preserved 19th-century architecture, right alongside high-end shopping.One of the more expensive neighborhoods in Manhattan to book a hotel room.
Upper West SideFamiliesDirect access to Central Park and its museums, in a genuinely residential setting.A longer subway ride or walk to Broadway theaters and downtown neighborhoods.

Our picks for New York City

A handful of editorial calls across every neighborhood above, not just the highest star rating — see each hotel's own card further down for the full case for and against it.

🏆 Our overall pickcitizenM New York Times SquareTimes Square & Theater District💰 Best valueWashington Square HotelGreenwich Village❤️ Best for couplesCrosby Street HotelSoHo👨‍👩‍👧 Best for familiesHotel BeaconUpper West Side✨ Best luxuryMandarin Oriental, New YorkUpper West Side📍 Best locationThe Knickerbocker HotelTimes Square & Theater District

A couple of hotels in Times Square & Theater District

Times Square & Theater District is the top-recommended area to stay in New York City.

citizenM New York Times Square

★★★★
  • 🏆 Our overall pick

Our take Our overall pick for New York City — a smartly designed, well-run hotel a short walk from Times Square that gets the basics right at a fair price, which makes it a strong first choice for almost any visitor.

Good for

  • First-time visitors

Travelers who want a smart, efficiently designed base right in the middle of Midtown without paying for a traditional luxury hotel.

Why we like it

  • One minute's walk from Times Square, with Central Park and Columbus Circle both within about five minutes on foot
  • Compact, well-designed rooms with a large bed, mood lighting, and a rain shower — more efficient than fussy
  • 24-hour lobby lounge for working or relaxing, plus a rooftop bar with skyline views
  • Consistent, modern feel across the whole hotel rather than dated rooms behind a nice lobby

What to know

  • Rooms are compact by design — there's no separate seating area, so it suits travelers who don't need extra space
  • Street noise from the Midtown crowds is audible on lower floors with windows facing the avenue
  • Check-in and lobby areas use self-service kiosks alongside staff, which some travelers prefer and others don't
Check availability on Booking.com

Sanctuary Hotel New York

★★★★

Our take A boutique option a short walk off Times Square itself, for travelers who want the convenience of the location on a slightly calmer block.

Good for

  • First-time visitors

Travelers who want to be a couple of minutes from Times Square without booking a room directly on it.

Why we like it

  • A two-minute walk from Times Square and the heart of the Theater District
  • Rooftop lounge and restaurant with city views, on top of the ground-floor restaurant and bar
  • Boutique-scale property with a more personal feel than the area's larger hotels

What to know

  • Rooms are on the smaller side, in keeping with the boutique format
  • Some rooms get limited natural light given the building's Midtown footprint
  • Street noise from the surrounding Theater District blocks can reach lower-floor, street-facing rooms
Check availability on Booking.com

Useful travel information

The US dollar is the currency. The subway runs 24/7 and is the fastest way to get around — pay with a contactless card or phone rather than buying a paper MetroCard. Sidewalks and stations are busy at almost any hour; keep bags zipped and stay alert around crowded platforms, same as in any big city.

Tips

  • Book Broadway tickets online in advance for the shows you actually want to see — popular titles sell out, especially on weekends.
  • Get a contactless payment card ready before you land — tapping it at the subway turnstile is faster and cheaper than the ticket machines.
  • Museums and major attractions get much less crowded right when they open — arrive early to skip the longest lines.

Frequently asked questions

Where should first-time visitors stay in New York City?
Stay in Midtown near Times Square to be close to Broadway, the subway hub, and most major sights. Prefer a quieter, more residential feel with easy Central Park access? The Upper West Side is a great alternative.
Is New York City walkable?
Yes, within each neighborhood. Manhattan's grid makes it easy to walk around any one area, and the subway covers the longer trips between neighborhoods in this guide.

Related destinations